One Friday morning, after I administered and then collected the first-graders’ spelling test (10 words that started with the letters Q-U plus a bonus word), a sensitive little boy, Michael, came to the front of the classroom and said shyly, “I was wondering how I did on the test.”
Mrs. T will grade them on Monday when she returns, I told him.
He was disappointed with that answer. His classmates were preoccupied with other matters more important to six year olds and didn’t notice our private conversation. What’s the harm, I thought, of checking his test myself? I found it and quickly scanned the words.
You got just one wrong, I told him cheerily. You left out the “e” in “quite.”
It was not the result he was expecting. Michael’s lower lip started to tremble.
No, that’s good, I reassured him.
“No,” he said. “My dad told me that I couldn’t have ice cream tonight unless I spelled all 10 words right, and I REALLY wanted ice cream!”
What had I done? My seemingly good intention was not going unpunished. Thinking quickly, I told him that he did get 10 words because he had spelled the bonus word correctly.
“It’s not the same,” Michael said.
But the test is not official until Mrs. T grades it, I said, somewhat desperate now.
Michael was inflexible. “I’m going to have to tell my dad when I get home today.”
Had it been possible I would have given ice cream on the spot to this noble little hero with his overdeveloped sense of righteousness.